• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine: Authentic Italian Flavors in Hartsville

Welcome to Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine, a charming family-owned gem in Hartsville, TN. Nestled on W McMurry Blvd, this delightful restaurant offers an authentic taste of Italy, where you can savor handmade dough and delectable dishes crafted with love. Guests rave about the generous portions, particularly the zesty calzones and mouthwatering pizzas, including the famous Big John. While service is often praised for its warmth and friendliness, occasional inconsistencies in food preparation have been noted. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their irresistible cannolis for dessert. Plain Jane's is a must-visit for Italian cuisine lovers seeking comfort and quality.

Photos & Gallery

Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine: Reviews & Ratings

Joel LaTraverse
Joel LaTraverse

We love this family owned little piece of pizza heaven in Hartsville! The Mom and Dad run this place very well. You can tell the dough is handmade, and the food is always excellent. The service and friendliness of the staff is top notch, and you feel right at home. You have to take a dessert home to eat later. If you haven't been here, then you are missing out.

Sara Hess
Sara Hess

The establishment was clean, service was good. Calzone and desrts were great. The Philly cheese sub was terrible, DRY and no sauce whatsoever (nor any mention that it's a sauce less sub) only a few (literally) pieces of thin slice onion and bell pepper. Although the bread of the sub was good.

Catherine Del Vecchio
Catherine Del Vecchio

We gave them a second chance. We had been getting chicken bacon ranch pizzas half with no onion. and they were phenomenal. Ordered the same tonight. Then, we got handed an onion pizza light onion on half and it was terrible. I didn’t want heavy onion. I wrote on the order “one half with no onion please”…. The food is not consistent at all. We’re done.

Laura Givens
Laura Givens

I had the baked ziti and my boyfriend had Jane’s Calzone. The calzone was huge! He brought the rest home to eat later. All the food was incredible. Service staff was very kind. We will be returning to eat here again.

robin sullivan
robin sullivan

By far the best pizza in town. The Big John ( new Yorker) is big enough to feed my family of five. John the owner is very kind and always makes you feel appreciated and important . By far my favorite restaurant. Thank you for being awesome and caring. It's rare, the cannolis are to die for. It's a must try if you ask me. So if you are looking for quality service and great authentic Italian cuisine plain Jane's is the place to go.

Location

If you find yourself in Hartsville, Tennessee, a visit to Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine is a must. Nestled at 116 W McMurry Blvd Ste: A, this family-owned gem has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels just like home. With a commitment to quality and handmade ingredients, you can taste the love that goes into every dish here.

As you step inside, you're greeted not just by the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza but also by the friendly staff who make it their mission to ensure every guest feels valued. The chefs at Plain Jane's pride themselves on crafting artisanal dough, evident in their offerings of incredible pizza and delectable calzones. One standout is the "Big John" New Yorker pizza, which is substantial enough to feed a family of five—a perfect choice for those who appreciate generous portions without sacrificing quality.

Flavors are elevated here, as demonstrated by their baked ziti and Jane’s massive calzone, both of which received rave reviews for their taste and portion size. It's a place where you can indulge in authentic Italian cuisine, from classic pasta dishes to inviting desserts—including cannolis that are hailed as "to die for" by dedicated fans.

While the culinary creations largely exceed expectations, occasional inconsistencies have been noted, such as mixed experiences with the Philly cheese sub. However, these moments do not overshadow the overwhelming positivity surrounding this establishment. Many patrons echo the sentiment that the ambiance and customer service are top-notch, often mentioning owners’ warm approach and genuine care towards their guests.

A visit to Plain Jane's is not just a meal but an experience. Whether you are taking a piece of their rich dessert home or enjoying a hearty pizza with friends, every interaction feels special. This cozy culinary escape brings not just food, but also a slice of Italian family spirit to Hartsville.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards